choanata wrote:While it's not their job to always write feel good stories, it is their job to entertain. Now you enjoy this arc, despite the fact that this has been the premise of what, 3, 4 or 5 stories before it, because it's approached differently in your words. my take is that it's the same story we've gotten just expanded and decompressed to the point of ridicule, but that's just my opinion.
Kind of how I couldn't care less about the whole Third Army thing, because we've been getting a "big crossover" in the Lantern books every year for the last three years.
I on the other hand do not find this rehash entertaining. You are invested in the characters, hell, so am I. The difference is that you would be happy reading a 12 issue yearlong story of John's losing fight with brain cancer while I would drop the book for anything else that had an iota of Green lanterns doing fun and entertaining Green Lantern stuff. Your love of the characters can carry you through countless issues where the protagonists don't do anything remotely close to what the book is based on.
And it's not that I don't want any non-Green Lantern stuff in the book. I DO like seeing the downtime. I DO enjoy character building. But this? They're not building character here. If anything it's recycling old character bits yet again. It's Martyr John all over again. And this isn't John's downtime. This is let's devote 6 issues to him being charged stupidly for a crime he needed to commit to save thousands.
Ugh. I don't know if that was a coherent argument, but I'm angry and tired now.
This is the way it usually goes for John:
John is responsible for some death, and he carries that weight around with him for years and years, never getting any resolution to it. Sometimes they'll teas us and tell us that he's coming to terms with it, but don't worry, they're just kidding. Meanwhile, the Guardians and entire GLC are basically fine with what happened, and barely ever mention it, except when expressing how sorry they feel for John. John hates what he did, and knows his mistakes killed people for no reason.
Here's what happened this time:
John is responsible for some death, and almost immediately gets called out on it by his superiors in the GLC. Weather or not he made the right decision is a divisive topic for every other Green Lantern, and it turns Oa into a powder keg. John hates what he did, but knows he had to do it.
...this is not the same old story recycled. The super-basic concept is, but this story is different.
This also makes for an interesting Guy Gardner story because it's a fight he can't win by punching someone in the face, and that's how he usually solves all of his problems. He knows he can't fight the Alpha Lanterns and win, and the Guardians
won't help him. He tried helping John the right way, and now that there's nothing left to do, he defaults back to classic Guy: make a ruckus and hope like hell it works out. Come to think of it, that bar scene with those bounty hunters is a nice little microcosm for Guy's entire character arc in this story: he tried to rein himself in, solve the conflict with his words, with reason, but it didn't work so he jumped in swinging.